New Arrivals – Page 3 – Knick Knack Toy Shack

Skip to content

?

Your treat bag is empty!

No tricks here. Let's fill it with tiny treasures.

Halloween toys
Trick-or-treat toys
$5 & under
Blind boxes
Clearance

Free US shipping on orders over $100

Tiny treasures under $5

Real Littles Puppy In My Bag (One B... $8.00
Micro Machines Series 1 Mystery Pac... $7.00
Cats Vs Pickles - 1 Random (Soft Pl... $6.00
Worlds Smallest Harmonica by Westmi... $8.00

See all $5 finds →

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Your cart

Loading...

Order special instructions

Order special instructions

Estimated total

$0.00 CAD

Taxes, discounts and shipping calculated at checkout.

Facebook
Instagram
X (Twitter)

Trick-or-treat toys, not candy: handouts under $5

Order by Oct 27 for Halloween delivery. Free US shipping over $100

30-day money-back guarantee on sealed items

New tiny toys land every week

Fall fun
Shop by brand
Shop by type
$5 & under
New arrivals
Blind boxes
Clearance

X (Twitter)
Facebook
Instagram

Search

Fall fun
Shop by brand
Shop by type
$5 & under
New arrivals
Blind boxes
Clearance

Search

Log in

Fresh off the truck

Just unboxed!

The newest toys to land on our shelves. New stuff shows up every week, so check back often.

50toys

Open the box!

Just landedJust landedFresh findsFresh findsNew every weekNew every weekBe the firstBe the firstHot off the truckHot off the truckJust landedJust landedFresh findsFresh findsNew every weekNew every weekBe the firstBe the firstHot off the truckHot off the truck

Sort by:

50 products

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

50 products

Sort by:

Remove all

50 products

Sasquinch - Zuru Fuggler 9" Festive Fugg Plush - Series 2

Sasquinch - Zuru Fuggler 9" Festive Fugg Plush - Series 2

Vendor:
Zuru

Regular price $38.00

Regular price Sale price $38.00
Keith Wreathington - Zuru Fuggler 9" Festive Fugg Plush - Series 2

Keith Wreathington - Zuru Fuggler 9" Festive Fugg Plush - Series 2

Vendor:
Zuru

Regular price $38.00

Regular price Sale price $38.00

1
2
3

A corner shop for curiosity.

A family-run toy shop. World's Smallest toys, Disney Doorables, Cats vs Pickles, GIANTmicrobes, blind boxes and the odd wonderful thing you didn't know you needed.

Facebook
Instagram
X (Twitter)

Shop

New arrivals
Shop by brand
Blind boxes
$5 & under
Buy the case
Gift cards

Help

Shipping & returns
Our 30-day guarantee
FAQ
Track my order
Contact us

About

Our story
Reviews
Blog

Legal

Privacy policy
Terms of service
Refund policy
Shipping policy
Do not sell my personal information

Say hello

info@knickknacktoyshack.com
A real person answers, usually within a day.

Get 10% off your first order

Email

Facebook
Instagram
X (Twitter)

Payment methods

© 2026, Knick Knack Toy Shack Powered by Shopify

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.